Ship Stats & Guides
Player Leaderboard
Captain Skill Calculator
54929
Fr05ty's attempt at divination: French Battleship Tech Tree (Premiums)!8/4/2017 2:38:02 PM
Published By: Fr05ty

Hello there! This is the continuation of my previous proposal for the French Battleship tech tree, with the premiums I'd want and expect to see in the game.

French Marine Nationale

Battleships

Flavour

French Battleships have several defining features that should make them stand out:

  • Smaller than average gun calibers at higher tiers
  • Outgun tiermates at low-mid tiers
  • Quadruple turrets
  • Poor shell ballistics at lower tiers but great shell ballistics at higher tiers
  • High muzzle velocities and heavy shells relative to the caliber
  • Good to great AA suites when upgraded (worse than USN)
  • Middling armour protection
  • Poor torpedo defense systems
  • Sub-par hitpoint pool

Tier

BB

Premium

2

Danton

3

Courbet

4

Bretagne

Lorraine

5

Normandie

Languedoc

6

Lyon / Strasbourg

Dunkerque

7

Marseille

Gascogne

8

Richelieu

Jean Bart

9

Alsace

10

Charlemagne

Premium Ships

Danton class Battleship (T2 Premium)

This ship was the last semi-dreadnought battleship to be commissioned for the French Navy. The ship was armed with a very large-caliber secondary battery and used steam turbines, which were unusual in pre-dreadnought designs.

Survivability

Displacement: 18,318t standard; 19,763t full (32,475hp standard; 34,180hp full)

Armour: 270-150mm belt, 300mm turrets, 280mm barbettes, 120mm secondary turrets, 300mm conning tower, 48+45mm deck

Weaponry

Main Battery: 2x2 305mm/45 Mle 1906 guns

Reload: 34s (1.76)

AP Shell: 432kg @783m/s (8200 damage)

HE Shell: 308kg @905m/s (4000 damage, 24% fire)

Traverse: ? degrees per second (?s per 180 degrees)

Secondary Battery: 6x2 240mm/50 Mle 1902 guns, 16x1 75mm/65 Mle 1908 guns

Reload: 30s (2) / 6s (10)

Shell: 220kg @800m/s AP (6000 damage) / 6.4kg @930m/s HE (1100 damage, 4% fire)

AA Battery: 12x1 75mm/50 Mle. 1908 guns (14.4dps @3km)

Mobility

Speed: 19kts - 22,500hp

Size: 146.6m long, 25.8m wide, 8.44m deep

Consumables

Consumables: Standard

Notes:

  • Used short shells which would have poor ballistics
  • Historic ROF was 1.5-2
Analysis

The Danton is the French counterpart to the Mikasa, but where the Mikasa is defined by its massive amount of guns, the Danton instead mounts a good amount of large-caliber guns. These guns fire quite slowly but pack a big punch, and anybody downrange from them is sure to feel their weight. It will never be the most competitive ship, but it will be a lot of fun if you enjoy fireworks!

 

Lorraine Battleship (T4 Premium)

The Lorraine was refitted several times throughout its service, being modified to carry aircraft and to serve with the Allied forces. Throughout her career she participated in both World Wars, carried French gold to Bermuda and bombarded German positions during Operation Dragoon.

Survivability

Displacement: 23,936t standard; 26,500t full (39,110hp standard; 42,140hp full)

Armour: 270mm belt, 340mm turrets, 170mm casemates, 314mm conning tower, 40mm deck

Weaponry

Main Battery: 4x2 340mm/45 Mle 1912 guns

Reload: 30s (2)

AP Shell: 575kg @780m/s (9400 damage)

HE Shell: 382kg @885m/s (4400 damage, 27% fire)

Traverse: ? degrees per second (?s per 180 degrees)

Secondary Battery: 14x1 138.6mm Mle 1910 guns, 4x2 100mm/45 Mle 1930 DP guns

Reload: 10s (6) / 4s (15)

HE Shell: 31.5kg @840m/s (1900 damage, 8% fire) / 13.5kg @780m/s (1400 damage, 6% fire)

AA Battery: 4x2 100mm/45 Mle. 1930 DP guns (27.2dps @5km), 8x1 37mm/50 Mle. 1925 guns (12.8dps @3km), 2x4 13.2mm/76 CAD Mle. 1929 (10dps @1.2km)

Mobility

Speed: 21.5kts - 43,000hp

Size: 166m long, 26.9m wide, 9.8m deep

Consumables

Consumables: Standard + 4 Seaplanes

Notes:

  • B hull:
    • Remove Seaplanes, 100mm secondaries, 13.2mm guns
    • Add 8x1 75mm/50 Mle 1922 (13.6dps@3km), 14x1 40mm/56 Bofors Mk3 (106.4dps@3.5km), 25x1 20mm/70 Mk4 (90dps@2km)
Analysis

The Lorraine is a decent if unspectacular tier 4 battleship, combining 8 guns with a middling secondary battery and a weak AA suite. The Lorraine’s strong points are its accuracy and its option to mount a B hull which would trade some of the secondaries and seaplanes for a powerful AA suite. If you like a ship like the Texas, which is an absolute nightmare to any aircraft within its matchmaking range that approaches it while still having a good few big guns to punch your enemies into submission, the Lorraine might be the ship you’re looking for.

 

Languedoc Fast Battleship (T5 Premium)

A proposed rework of the Normandie class after the experience gained during the war. It featured a more elongated hull, improved elevation for its main battery and torpedo tubes on deck. It was a prototype of fast battleship as it carried heavy armour and a battleship’s main battery while being faster than ships of the line.


Survivability

Displacement: 28,570?t standard; 32,500?t full (44,585hp standard; 49,225hp full)

Armour: 300mm belt, 340mm turrets, 300mm conning tower, 120mm deck, Torpedo bulges

Weaponry

Main Battery: 3x4 340mm/45 Mle 1912 guns

Reload: 32s (1.88)

AP Shell: 555kg @794m/s (9300 damage)

HE Shell: 382kg @885m/s (4400 damage, 27% fire)

Traverse: ? degrees per second (?s per 180 degrees)

Secondary Battery: 24x1 138.6mm Mle 1910 guns

Reload: 10s (6)

HE Shell: 31.5kg @840m/s (1900 damage, 8% fire)

Torpedo Battery: 2x3 550mm torpedoes

Model: 550mm 19DT Toulon

Warhead: 238kg (12233 damage, 199% flooding)

Speed: 57kts @6km

AA Battery: 6x1 47mm/50 Mle. 1902 guns (7.2dps @2.5km)

Mobility

Speed: 24/27kts - 80,000hp

Size: 188.6m long, 27m wide, 8.65m deep

Consumables

Consumables: Standard + 1 Aircraft

Notes:

  • Compared to C hull tech-tree:
    • Increased displacement by 3,340t
    • Hull length increased by 12m
    • Increased speed by 3kts
    • Improved deck to 120mm
    • Same torpedo bulges
    • Lacking AA suite
    • Addition of 2x3 550mm torpedo tubes
    • Addition of floatplane fighter
    • Used short shells which would have poor ballistics
    • Reduced range (~1.5km)
    • Reduced accuracy (0.1/0.2 worse sigma)
    • Reduced ROF (2s extra reload)
  • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Normandie-class_battleship
Analysis

The Languedoc trades the upgraded shells that the Normandie carries (along with their improved AP damage, shell drag and penetration), some of the Normandie’s accuracy, range and most of its AA suite for triple torpedo tubes on each side, improved deck armour, torpedo bulges, speed and the capability of launching a floatplane fighter. In essence, the Languedoc becomes faster and more durable while giving up her long-range firepower, becoming much more effective at brawling ranges where she can use her torpedoes. It must be said that even though the Languedoc is more durable nominally, the fact that she has to be much closer to her enemy to be effective means that she’ll be an easier target and thus her durability may be overstated. The Languedoc additionally suffers from a meager anti-aircraft battery that is only barely offset by her capability to launch a floatplane fighter. This won’t be a massive relief but will panic bombers on occasion, still, avoid enemy aircraft when at all possible and the Languedoc will surely reward you.

 

Gascogne class Battleship (T7 Premium)

A derived design from the Richelieu class, the Gascogne used a more conventional main armament configuration with minor improvements over the Richelieu. The limited shipbuilding capacity of the French dry docks meant it was never laid down.

Survivability

Displacement: 35,000t standard; 48,000t full (52,180hp standard; 67,500hp full)

Armour: 320mm belt, 430-170mm turrets, 260mm conning tower, 150mm deck

Weaponry

Main Battery: 2x4 380mm/45 Mle 1935 guns

Reload: 32s (1.88)

AP Shell: 890kg @785m/s (11700 damage)

HE Shell: 884kg @800m/s (5800 damage, 42% fire)

Traverse: 5 degrees per second (36s per 180 degrees)

Secondary Battery: 3x3 152mm/55 Mle 1936 guns, 8x2 100mm/45 Mle 1931 guns

Reload: 9.2s (6.5) / 4s (15)

HE Shell: 55kg @870m/s (2200 damage, 12% fire) / 13.5kg @780m/s (1400 damage, 6% fire)

AA Battery: 3x3 152mm/55 Mle 1936 DP guns (~25 @5km), 8x2 100mm/45 Mle 1931 DP guns (54.4dps @5km), 4x4 37mm/50 Mle 1937 (12.8dps @3km), 2x2 37mm/50 Mle 1933 (4.6dps @3km), 5x4 13.2mm/76 Mle 1929 (25dps @1.2km)

Mobility

Speed: 30kts - 150,000hp

Size: 247.9m long, 33m wide, 9.6m deep

Consumables

Consumables: Standard + 2 Seaplanes

Notes:

  • Gascogne as laid down
Analysis

The Gascogne brings the great guns of the Richelieu class to a tier lower and in a more conventional layout. This layout is not without its advantages and disadvantages; whereas the Richelieu is basically incapable of firing behind itself if being chased, the Gascogne doesn’t have that weakness, instead trading that capability for the Richelieu’s capability of firing all its main battery while tanking with the bow. This change in main battery layout is Gascogne’s biggest weakness as it means that to bring its great main battery guns to bear, it will have to show part of its broadside to the enemy, although she does have a very respectable armoured belt that should bounce incoming fire if properly angled. Another weakness of the Gascogne is its meager anti-aircraft suite which is representative of French shipbuilding at the time, where the importance of anti-aircraft weaponry was not yet fully understood. These two weaknesses cannot hide however the fact that Gascogne is a very powerful vessel with a massive hitpoint pool, a solid armour scheme, a good secondary battery and a great top speed. It is when compared to a ship like the Colorado or the Nagato that the Gascogne definitely has enough in it to fight them so long as it doesn’t show broadside or planes aren’t involved.

 

Jean Bart Battleship (T8 Premium)

The Jean Bart was still incomplete when France fell to the German advance. She was sunk, refloated and completed in 1955 with vastly improved anti-aircraft armament compared to its sister ship Richelieu. She had a very short life in service.

Survivability

Displacement: 35,000t standard; 48,950t full (52,180hp standard; 68,655hp full)

Armour: 330mm belt, 430-140mm turrets, 260mm conning tower, 150mm deck

Weaponry

Main Battery: 2x4 380mm/45 Mle 1935 guns

Reload: 27s (2.2)

AP Shell: 885kg @800m/s (11800 damage)

HE Shell: 879kg @632m/s (5800 damage, 42% fire)

Traverse: 5 degrees per second (36s per 180 degrees)

Secondary Battery: 3x3 152mm/55 Mle 1936 guns, 12x2 100mm/55 CAD Mle 1945 guns

Reload: 9.2s (6.5) / 3s (20)

HE Shell: 55kg @870m/s (2200 damage, 12% fire) / 13.32kg @855m/s (1400 damage, 5% fire)

AA Battery: 3x3 152mm/55 Mle 1936 DP guns (~25 @5km), 12x2 100mm/55 CAD Mle 1945 DP guns (177.6dps @5km), 14x2 57mm/60 ACAD Mle 1951 (357dps @4.5km)

Mobility

Speed: 32kts - 162,000hp

Size: 247.9m long, 35.4m wide, 9.9m deep

Consumables

Consumables: Standard

Notes:

  • 1955 fit
Analysis

The Jean Bart is the Richelieu’s much younger brother and it has all the new cool gadgets like those nice 57mm anti-aircraft that you’ve seen in the Henri IV and the 100mm secondaries you saw in the Saint-Louis. Obviously, the Jean Bart is going to be an AA beast as it was only finished being fitted out in 1955 and thus anti-air capabilities top of the list for a battleship’s protection, being the best at tier 8 by quite a margin and comparable to an Iowa. As befits a premium, Jean Bart should not be better than its tech-tree equivalent, and since it is heavier and has a better AA battery, her ergonomics will most likely take a hit to balance her out. Possibilities for this include worsening her rudder shift time or reducing her sigma values. It is very likely that the Jean Bart will end up overshadowing her tech-tree sister.


So what do you think? Would you be happy with these battleships coming into the game? Would you change these premiums to put in other ships instead of the ones I chose? Let me know through the forums or Reddit!
 
PS: Special thanks to Garclicdesign and the guys at shipbucket for making all the amazing line art that I've used here, definitely go check their other work as it's beautifully done and very complete.
 
Comments
Fr05ty's Last 3 Articles and/or Reviews
Published by Fr05ty 2 months ago /Tech-Tree Proposal: French Battleships
Welcome to a new pet project of mine, tech tree proposals. What I attempt to do in these articles is that I try to make a coherent and clear proposal as to what I think we can expect from Wargaming if they ever make such a tech-tree line. Might even work as a proposal for Wargaming to put something in (in the unlikely case that they haven't mapped all this)...
This article will touch only on the tech-tree ships, the snippets on each premium ship will come at a later date. For each ship, I provide the layout of how the ship's weaponry is distributed, its technical specifications and with the same formulas I used for the ADLA articles, their in-game values. Finally, I provide a small piece of analysis of what I think about the ship and how it'd fit with its tiermates. Essentially, each of the ships gets a mini-ADLA with all the information you might be looking for to compare it to its tiermates that are already in-game. Let's hope we see these ships in the virtual seas soon!
Published by Fr05ty 3 months ago /A Detailed Look At: HNLMS Karel Doorman (QH1)
The Karel Doorman was the first aircraft carrier possessed by the Dutch Koninklijke Marine. Built as an escort carrier from a merchant ship under construction in Scotland, the Karel Doorman was first known as the HMS Nairana of the British Royal Navy and escorted convoys from the Mediterranean to the Arctic with great success. Inducted into the Dutch Royal Navy after the war, she was returned to the Royal Navy after a couple of years and finally ended as a merchant ship.
 
Throughout this article I look at how the Karel Doorman could make its way into the game, carefully analysing every aspect of it and talking of its short history in action. The Karel Doorman was the first vessel of its kind in service of the Dutch people, worthy of its inclusion as a mighty vessel in the service of one of the most storied and under-represented navies in the world.
Published by Fr05ty 6 months ago /Battlecruiser Wednesdays: Design 1047
Welcome to the tenth article from our Battlecruiser Wednesdays cycle! We'll be taking a look at a different battlecruiser design each Wednesday and analysing how it could be implemented in-game by using our familiar "A Detailed Look At" format.
This week: I'll be taking a look at the one of the proposed battlecruisers for the Dutch Koninklijke Marine, the Design 1047 which I've dubbed the De Zeven Provincien. This design was the Dutch response to Imperial Japanese expansionist ambitions, and to protect the Dutch East Indies which were vital due to their resources. The design was done with the assistance of the Germans, and a tiny bit from the Italians, which resulted in what might affectionately be called the Scharnhorst's Dutch cousin. A design created to hunt Imperial Japanese cruisers with impunity, the 1047 design is a thoroughbred battlecruiser which would have represented the pinnacle of Dutch naval ambitions. It was not meant to be, as all work on these ships was halted with the German invasion of the Netherlands and yet again, the Dutch's attempt at making their own capital ship ended with the outbreak of a World War.
Step inside, read the article to see just how the De Zeven Provincien would stack up in-game and let us know what you think of this class making its way into the game!
Visit Fr05ty's Article Library